Jump to content

Search the Community

Showing results for tags 'psychology'.



More search options

  • Search By Tags

    Type tags separated by commas.
  • Search By Author

Content Type


Forums

  • BEAR BULL TRADERS FORUMS
    • Welcome: Bear Bull Traders Forums
    • Members Introductions & Meetups
    • Day Trading
    • Swing Trading
    • Options Trading
    • Forex and Currency Markets
    • Trading Psychology
    • Off Topic
    • Success Webinar Questions
    • BBT en Español
    • Forum Support
    • BBT Trader's Challenge
  • Chicago Area Bear Bull Traders's Chicago Area BBT Topics
  • Pica Mucho BBT's Conversaciones
  • SINGAPORE's Topics
  • Denver, Colorado's Topics
  • BBT DC/DMV AREA's Topics
  • San Francisco Bay Area's Topics
  • BBT Toronto, ON's Topics
  • Texas BBT - Everything is bigger here's A club for Texas BBT members to get together
  • Texas BBT - Everything is bigger here's Let's try and organize some Meetups for the spring!
  • BBT Ottawa, Canada's Topics
  • BBT Vancouver, BC's Forums
  • BBT Australia's Topics
  • BBT - SoCal Traders's Topics
  • BBT MONTREAL, QC's Topics
  • NY Metro BBT's Topics
  • Seattle/Bellevue's Topics
  • BBT Detroit's Topics
  • Europe's Topics
  • North Carolina's Topics
  • the Ladies Lounge's Discussion
  • ARIZONA BBT's Discussions
  • BBT - United Kingdom's Topics

Calendars

  • Community Calendar

Marker Groups

There are no results to display.


Find results in...

Find results that contain...


Date Created

  • Start

    End


Last Updated

  • Start

    End


Filter by number of...

Joined

  • Start

    End


Group


Location

miles from

About Me

Found 3 results

  1. Hi everyone, (sorry if its a long post, just want to get my thoughts out and see if anyone has comments) I wanted to know if there was a topic or experience someone has had on having your rules too strict & it affecting your trading? June 23: I was on SIM / QR (Quote Replay) for 4 months (took about 60 trades) and had a profitable edge at the end of those 4 months so I decided to go live. In the first week I had a decreasing equity curve (8 trades over a week) and no green trades past 2R. Firstly, I re-evaluated why I was losing and thought I was not choosing the same stocks as in my SIM/QR. So and went back to compare the trades I was doing before, I made some small tweaks to my trade book (added more required confirmations) and went back to live. Another 4 red days in a row. July 6: Next I thought it was my psychology because I was breaking a lot of my rules , I ended up finishing Trading in The Zone (which is a great book) and I began to understand myself more. I thought I was breaking my rules because I thought I was outsmarting the market and ignoring my rules because I expected the market to behave how I wanted to. (Which was wrong and since thing have fixed this mindset; I truly believe the market is unpredictable and must follow my rules like a casino). Went back to live and 3 red days in a row. July 28: At this point, I'm like wtf man. So I dig deeper into myself and my 4 months of SIM & I think have found the source of my problem. During my SIM / QR training I tried many different strategies but really enjoyed (& saw the potential) trading at open specifically 60 min Breakouts. Using Aiman's tradebook as a starting point, I began just focusing on these set ups. During this training I still felt unsure about the direction of the breakout can go and felt it was very random. I wanted to know which direction it would go and predict it well. In order to fill this fear of entering into a "wrong trade" I went to learn more about the market. (I know understand this was a wrong mindset because I was looking for certainty in the market where there is none.) Doing some youtube searches I came across the MACD Indicator and instantly loved it. It made me feel more confident and certain in my directions / timing of breakouts; so I added criteria to my tradebook based upon repeating (successful) MACD patterns on the 60min chart. Maybe around month 3 of training I added these criteria. Solution: Looking at all my recent live trades in retrospect I think my problem for not being consistently profitable is my over reliance on the MACD indicator in my 60min BO tradebook and too many other requirements to enter a trade. By having created such a strict tradebook (to compensate my previous fear of uncertainty) I have created another psychology problem in my trading. I have been breaking my rules many of the times in LIVE because I simply can't find stocks that match perfectly with previous MACD patterns and other requirements to enter a trade. Next Steps: 1) I am going to stop trading LIVE for now and really review all my trades I have previously taken in SIM / QR. 2) I am going to remove the MACD indicator from my charts and tradebook. Then I will need to re-trade all my trades again to see if I truly have a winning edge. (I'm pretty sure I do but numbers don't lie so I need to redo my stats to make sure before I go back to live) 3) Instead of over relying on the MACD indicator, I'm going to continue improving my daily chart patterns and selection. (Which I have improved a lot in the past weeks) 4) I want to get more feedback / advice on how I should go about adding requirements or rules to my tradebook. For instance what I have been doing is cross refencing criteria on all my trades and analyzing common patterns (ex. Do not enter if 8am 60min candle is Long Wicky Hammer) because I noticed the stock never went my way (4 out of 4 times the candle appeared) so I would add that to my tradebook to avoid. In retrospect, I do not know if by adding avoiding criteria is in fact a psychological compensation of fear avoidance or if its smart because it will save me money. Note: Quote Replay was used for trades during Jan 2021 - Feb 2021. See my tradebook for ref. Any feedback on my entry would be super helpful! (Takeaways: over reliance on indicators, too strict tradebook, thoughts / experiences of adding a rule to an existing tradebook based on failed trade(s) / pain avoidance) ChristianRodriguez_TradeBook.pdf
  2. Good morning BBT, Something that I am interested in discussing is what people's opinions are about trading either the long side or the short side of the markets. I'm interested in the difference in strategies for both day trading (short-term), and swing trading (long-term). I find that I am biased to play the long side for short-term trades, and then the short side for more longer-term moves. My father was a stock broker and trader during the 80's and 90's, and he was always a short side kind of guy, constantly paying monthly premiums to hold position, but seriously cashing in when the price broke and fell hard, with profit well exceeding his total expenses paid on the position. He was very much influenced by the theory that fear is a more potent emotion than greed, and that while not every fearful person gets greedy, every greedy person does experience fear. I'd also like to see a discussing about the psychology behind this. What is the psychology of trading the long side during short-term moves, or during long term moves? Vice versa, what is the thought process of someone that takes the short-side during the short-term, or long-term. What does everyone else think? - Andrew from Jersey aka Tracksuit Trader
  3. Hey Everyone, The power of the BBT community is greater than anyone person, so I am seeking the assistance from everyone in community for ideas of what type of psychology topics, services, or other items you would like to see BBT offer. What do you like, what do not like, what do you want to see. I listed a few to start the conversation but I am really looking for ideas from the community. Do not be afraid to throw out an idea, if we don't know what you want we can't see what the feasibility is. - Psychology Lessons - Having a Trading Psychologist available for members - Live Psychology Lessons or "How to" Webinars Looking forward to all the great ideas and thoughts on the above.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.