@dmiles, glad to hear that you are having success with these scanners, and good to see this thread revived. I’ve had some similar success. I copied/pasted the original formulas that Matt C provided and have been monitoring the various alerts for the past four months. Here’s what I’ve seen:
The majority of alerts come from the “S2-S3 Long” and “R2-R3 Short” settings. There are typically 5 or 6 of these a day, and I’ve developed a tradebook for these that works quite well for me- wait for the price to touch S3 or R3, get a 5-minute candle to close in the direction of the reversal, and simultaneously have two consecutive one-minute candles as confirmation. I’ll enter when a new 5-minute candle confirms the reversal AND the third consecutive one-minute candle continues the trend with conviction and volume. I set stop at the base of the previous one-minute candle (which is the second of the three one-minute candles). I find that forcing myself to wait for a 5-minute candle to complete itself keeps me out of some tests of S3/R3 before the reversal gains its ultimate momentum. I think of this as a conservative entry/confirmation with an aggressive stop that is justified by the consistency of the set-up. My trade management is still evolving, but I'll often get a full S3-R3 or R3-S3 traverse, and even if not, I'm able to follow the VPA to manage the trade with partials that typically yield a 2R to 3R return.
The other alerts occur sporadically and I too have not been able to rely on them for a consistent set-up. For now, the base plays described above are suiting me just fine. I consider them to be a valuable tool in finding symbols that check the “Where” part of the Cam strategies, and my own entry/stop criteria serves as the “When”.
The symbols that trigger are sometimes also on my Watch list and have catalysts, but quite often they come from “off the radar” as symbols that I would otherwise not be following. It appears that the volume settings in Matt’s scripts are quite effective at finding symbols that are moving.
I’d love to see some renewed interest in this forum for these alerts, perhaps a new thread, and should the conversation evolve I’d be willing to participate.